How to Choose a Buy-Side QoE Provider in the Lower Middle Market

How to Choose a Buy-Side QoE Provider in the Lower Middle Market

Searching for the best QoE firms for a lower-middle-market deal puts you in a strange market. There is no ranking that means anything, no Michelin guide for diligence, and the brand names you recognize are built for deals ten times your size. Meanwhile the work you are buying is the work that decides whether you overpay by a turn of EBITDA.

I have bought diligence from both ends of this market: as a private equity investor with a Big-4 budget, and as a searcher buying my own company with every dollar scrutinized. What I learned is that choosing a provider is itself a diligence exercise, and buyers who run it well use criteria, not logos. Here are the six that matter, how to test each one, and the traps on either end of the price range.

The six-criteria scorecard

Score every provider you talk to against these six. The deeper dives follow, and the downloadable version at the end formats this as a side-by-side comparison sheet.

Criterion What to ask The red flag
1. Who does the work Exactly who will be in my workpapers, and is the person selling me also the person doing the analysis? A confident partner in the sales call who cannot name the team
2. LMM fluency How many sub-$25M, owner-operated deals did you work in the last year? War stories that all start at $100M revenue
3. The sample report Can I see a redacted sample before engaging? No sample, or one that buries the answer on page 40
4. Defensibility How have your adjustments held up with sellers’ accountants and lenders’ credit committees? No examples of findings surviving a fight
5. Speed What is your start date and committed timeline, in writing? A quote in weeks-from-now before work even begins
6. Price structure Fixed fee, scoped after a look at the books? Hourly billing, or a quote without seeing anything

1. Who actually does the work

The industry’s open secret is partner-sold, analyst-delivered: a persuasive partner wins the engagement, then a rotating bench of juniors you never meet performs it. Nothing about that structure is dishonest, but you should know you are buying it, because the judgment calls in a QoE, which add-backs survive, what a finding is worth, live with whoever is actually in the workpapers.

Ask for names. Ask whether the person in the sales call will review every schedule. Ask what happens if that person is on another deal when yours hits a snag. A firm built partner-led will answer in one sentence; a firm built on leverage will answer in an org chart.

2. Lower-middle-market fluency

A team calibrated on $500M companies misreads a $4M one in both directions at once. It flags normal owner-operator behavior as chaos, and it misses the risks that actually live in small companies: payroll tax exposure, related-party rent, below-market family wages, cash revenue that never touches the books.

The test is recency and volume: how many owner-operated, sub-$25M deals in the last twelve months? You want a team whose pattern library was built on companies like your target, because pattern recognition is most of what you are paying for.

3. The sample-report test

Ask for a redacted sample before you engage. It is the cheapest diligence you will ever run on a provider, and it is remarkable how much it reveals. You are looking for three things: an executive summary that leads with the answer, findings quantified in dollars rather than described in adjectives, and schedules a lender can lift straight into a credit memo.

If the sample reads like a compliance document, your report will too. And if the firm will not share one at all, ask yourself what the paying clients received that cannot survive redaction.

4. Defensibility under scrutiny

Your report will be attacked from two directions: the seller’s accountant disputing every adjustment, and your lender’s credit committee stress-testing the number their loan depends on. A QoE that cannot survive both is a shelf document.

Ask providers how their adjustments have held up in actual retrades. Ask whether lenders have accepted their reports without commissioning re-work. Ask for an example of a finding the seller fought and lost. Firms that do defensible work tell these stories easily, because the stories are the product.

5. Speed inside the exclusivity window

Most LOIs give you 60 to 90 days, with financing and legal queued behind diligence. A provider quoting six to eight weeks because of backlog is spending your negotiating window on their staffing problem. The benchmarks: a full-scope QoE should run three to four weeks from data delivery, and a QoE Lite can land inside ten business days.

Ask about the start date, not just the duration. A fast team that cannot start for a month is slower than a steady one that starts Monday. And get the commitment in writing alongside the fee.

6. Price structure, and the two traps

Push for a fixed fee, scoped after the provider has actually looked at the books. Hourly billing puts the cost risk and the timeline risk on you simultaneously, and reluctance to quote fixed is information about how well a firm knows this market. The ranges to expect: $10,000 to $20,000 for QoE Lite on deals under $5M, $25,000 to $50,000 for full scope from a boutique. Our pricing guide covers what moves you inside those ranges.

The traps sit at the extremes. Below $10,000 you are usually buying a template: no proof of cash, no working capital analysis, no one senior in the workpapers. This is one of the largest financial decisions of your life; don’t skimp on the very work that may save you from blowing it up. Above $100,000 you are usually buying a logo, and in the lower middle market the logo is rarely required: lenders care that the work is independent, rigorous, and legible, not whose letterhead it arrived on. The Big-4 vs. boutique trade-offs get their own article.

What is deliberately not a criterion

Infographic highlighting three factors for choosing a buy-side Quality of Earnings provider: check delivery fit, value direct access to the team, and prioritize expertise over big-name brand recognition.

Brand prestige. A national firm’s name on the cover does not change your lender’s underwriting, and it does not make the add-back analysis sharper. The question is never who has the most famous letterhead; it is who will put a partner in your workpapers, inside your window, at a fee that matches your deal. Relationships beat logos in this market, which is exactly why we built our practice partner-led and white-glove: the person you scope with is the person who answers the phone when the seller’s CFO says something odd on a Tuesday.

Frequently asked questions

Who are the best QoE firms for small deals?

There is no meaningful ranking. The right firm for a lower-middle-market deal is partner-led, fluent in owner-operated companies, fixed-fee, and fast enough for your exclusivity window. Score candidates against criteria, not brand recognition.

How do I evaluate a QoE provider before engaging?

Run the six-criteria scorecard: who does the work, LMM fluency, the sample-report test, defensibility, committed speed, and fixed-fee pricing. The sample report and the staffing answer reveal the most.

Do lenders care which QoE firm I use?

Lenders care that the work is independent and rigorous, and that the schedules hold up in underwriting. Very few LMM lenders require a national firm; many accept any credible independent provider. Ask your lender before you pay a brand premium.

Should I just use my CPA?

No. Your CPA may be excellent, but lenders and investors want independence, and transaction diligence is a different discipline from accounting. Use your CPA as a reviewer, not as the provider.

Score us against the list

Download the scorecard, put System Six in one column, and put anyone else in the next. Then send us the CIM: a partner will scope your deal, name the exact team, and quote a fixed fee with a start date. If we are not the right fit for your deal, the scorecard will show you who is.

Download the QoE provider evaluation scorecard from System Six.

About System Six

System Six is a Seattle-based outsourced bookkeeping, accounting, payroll, and CFO advisory firm serving consulting and professional services businesses. We work with more than 175 businesses, our team averages over 10 years of accounting experience, and we’ve processed more than $100 million in payroll. Clients rate us 9.5 out of 10 on likelihood to recommend, and over half of our new clients come from referrals. We work on a fixed weekly fee with no long-term contracts. Learn more at systemsix.com.

The Buy-Side QoE Day-One Data Request List

The Buy-Side QoE Day-One Data Request List

The quality of earnings clock does not start when you sign the LOI. It starts when the seller delivers the data. Which means the single highest-leverage document in your diligence process is the request list you send on day one, and most buyers get it wrong in one of two directions.

Some send nothing for a week while the provider gets engaged, burning exclusivity on logistics. Others send a 150-line everything list cribbed from a private equity template, and watch a one-bookkeeper seller freeze. I have made the second mistake myself: ask an owner-operator for board minutes and a fixed-asset register on day one and you don’t get documents faster, you get a spooked seller and a stalled deal.

The fix is a lean list. Request only the most important things, the documents that actually gate the QoE work, and let everything else come in a second wave once the engagement is moving. Here is the list we send, why each item is on it, and what deliberately is not.

Why day-one data drives the whole timeline

A full-scope QoE runs three to four weeks from data delivery, and a QoE Lite can land inside ten business days. From data delivery. A seller who takes three weeks to produce bank statements adds three weeks to your deal, and most LOIs give you 60 to 90 days of exclusivity with financing and legal queued behind diligence. The math is unforgiving: every day between LOI signature and a complete data room is a day subtracted from your negotiating window.

So the list goes out the day the LOI is signed, ideally attached to the same email. Sellers are most responsive in the first week after signing, while momentum and goodwill are at their peak. Use that week for data, not for scheduling calls about data.

The day-one list: 12 items

Everything below should exist already in a reasonably run business. Nothing requires the seller to create new analysis, which is exactly why it is reasonable to ask for all of it immediately.

Financial statements and books

  1. Monthly financial statements, trailing 36 months. P&L and balance sheet by month, not annual summaries. Monthly grain is what makes trend, seasonality, and working capital analysis possible.
  2. Trial balances, same periods. The bridge between the statements and the underlying books. If the statements and the trial balance disagree, that is finding number one.
  3. Accounting file access. Read-only access to QuickBooks Online, Xero, or whatever system the books live in. One login replaces fifty document requests, and a seller’s reluctance here is itself diagnostic.
  4. Year-end tax returns, three years. The one set of numbers prepared under penalty. The gap between tax returns and the CIM’s EBITDA is often where the first real conversation starts.

Cash

  1. Bank statements, all operating accounts, trailing 24 months. The raw material for proof of cash, which is the credibility floor of the whole engagement. This is the request sellers most often drag on, so it goes first in the email, not last.
  2. Merchant processor and payment platform statements. Square, Stripe, PayPal, point-of-sale reports. Revenue that routes around the bank account has to be traced through its own rails.

Revenue and customers

  1. Customer-level revenue, trailing 36 months. By customer by month or quarter, ideally straight from the invoicing system. This powers concentration, retention, and cohort analysis; without it, revenue quality is a guess.
  2. Top-10 customer contracts. What actually holds the biggest relationships: terms, pricing, renewal dates, change-of-control clauses. The handshake accounts reveal themselves by what is missing.
  3. Accounts receivable and deferred revenue detail. Aged AR plus anything collected but not yet earned. Deferred revenue is a debt-like item, dollar for dollar, and it hides here.

People and obligations

  1. Payroll register, trailing 12 months. Every person, their comp, and their role, including family members and the owner. This is where normalized owner comp and below-market wages get tested.
  2. Debt schedule and any leases. Everything the business owes and every contract it cannot walk away from: loans, lines, equipment leases, the building lease, related-party arrangements above all.
  3. Add-back support. The seller’s own schedule of claimed adjustments with backup for each. Asking on day one sets the expectation that every add-back will need evidence, which improves the quality of the conversation from the start.

That is the whole list. Twelve items, all of which exist already, most of which export in minutes from the systems that produced them.

What deliberately is not on it

Infographic highlighting four principles for managing a buy-side Quality of Earnings data request: keep the list focused, avoid unnecessary requests, protect deal momentum, and request additional documents in two waves.

No board minutes, no insurance policies, no fixed-asset registers, no org charts, no vendor contracts, no five-year projections. Some of that matters later, and your QoE team will request it in a targeted second wave once the first-pass analysis shows where to dig. Day one is for the documents that gate the work, nothing else.

Two reasons to hold the line on this. First, seller psychology: a lean, obviously reasonable list signals a professional buyer and keeps momentum, while an overwhelming one reads as hostility or inexperience and can kill the deal in week one. Second, focus: fifty extra documents on day one do not speed anything up, because the analysis cannot use them until the core twelve arrive anyway.

How to send it

  • Attach the list to the LOI-signing email, with a shared folder already set up. Never make the seller build the data room.
  • Name a single point of contact on each side. Document requests die in group threads.
  • Offer the easy path: if exporting is a burden, read-only system access substitutes for most of the list.
  • Set a soft deadline a week out and a standing fifteen-minute call to clear blockers. What gets scheduled gets delivered.

Frequently asked questions

What documents does a QoE require?

The core set: monthly financials and trial balances for three years, tax returns, 24 months of bank statements, customer-level revenue, payroll detail, the debt schedule, and support for claimed add-backs. Everything else comes in targeted follow-ups.

How long should the seller take to deliver?

A week is a healthy target for the core list. Slower than two weeks usually means the books are in worse shape than represented, which is itself diligence information.

Should I send the request list before the LOI is signed?

Share the list’s scope during LOI negotiation so nothing surprises the seller, but send the formal request at signing. Asking for bank statements before exclusivity tends to go nowhere.

Is this list different for a QoE Lite?

Barely. QoE Lite leans hardest on the bank statements, financials, and add-back support, but the lean list above serves both scopes, which is another argument for keeping it lean.

Get the working version

The downloadable version of this list is formatted to forward straight to a seller, with a tab for tracking what has arrived. It is the same one we attach to our own engagement kickoffs.

Download the buy-side QoE data-request list from System Six.

About System Six

System Six is a Seattle-based outsourced bookkeeping, accounting, payroll, and CFO advisory firm serving consulting and professional services businesses. We work with more than 175 businesses, our team averages over 10 years of accounting experience, and we’ve processed more than $100 million in payroll. Clients rate us 9.5 out of 10 on likelihood to recommend, and over half of our new clients come from referrals. We work on a fixed weekly fee with no long-term contracts. Learn more at systemsix.com.

Taking Client Payments? A Quick Guide to Staying Compliant

Taking Client Payments? A Quick Guide to Staying Compliant

The short answer: If your firm accepts credit or debit cards, the Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS) applies to you, however small you are. Most service businesses sit in the smallest merchant tier, which means filing a self-assessment questionnaire once a year and keeping card numbers out of your inbox, spreadsheets and files. The easiest route to payment processing compliance is to let your processor’s hosted invoice or payment link collect the card, so it never touches your systems.

Dana’s bookkeeper found it on a Tuesday, three lines from the bottom of the merchant statement: “PCI NON-VALIDATION FEE — $39.95.”

Dana runs a 14-person HR consulting firm outside Seattle. She’d never heard of PCI. Neither had her office manager, who’d quietly done everyone a favor for years: a spreadsheet of client card numbers, so she could charge monthly retainers without sending a reminder. A few clients emailed their numbers in. One read his over the phone, and the digits landed on a yellow sticky note curling at the edge of a monitor.

The fee wasn’t new. It had shown up every month for fourteen months, about $560 in all, tucked between processing charges nobody reads.

“I thought the payment company handled all that,” Dana said.

Lots of owners believe that. It’s half right. Your processor guards its own systems; your inbox and spreadsheets are on you. Here’s what PCI compliance actually asks of a service firm, why it matters more than a small fee suggests, and how to handle it in an afternoon.

What is PCI DSS, and does it apply to a firm my size?

Start with the PCI DSS basics. Five card brands (Visa, Mastercard, American Express, Discover and JCB) created the PCI Security Standards Council to write one rulebook for anyone who stores, processes or transmits card data. That rulebook is PCI DSS. It isn’t a federal law. It’s a condition of the agreement you signed to accept cards, and your processor enforces it.

Size doesn’t get you out. It just changes the paperwork.

Visa sorts merchants into four levels. Level 4 covers businesses with fewer than 20,000 online Visa transactions a year, plus most other merchants processing under a million. That’s almost every consulting and professional services firm. At Level 4, you fill out a self-assessment questionnaire, or SAQ, once a year and confirm you follow the rules that fit how you take payments. The current version of the standard is 4.0.1, and every requirement in it has been mandatory since March 2025. The grace periods are over.

So where does that monthly fee come in? When your processor doesn’t receive your questionnaire, it may add a non-compliance (or “non-validation”) charge until you file. Small merchants commonly see somewhere between $20 and $100 a month.

Think of it as a smoke detector chirping down the hall. Annoying, easy to tune out, and not really the problem. The problem is whatever it’s trying to warn you about.

Where does card data hide in a service business?

Infographic showing where sensitive payment card data can be exposed in a service business, including shared files and CRM systems, expanded PCI compliance scope, and the risk of storing card security codes.

Take a slow walk through your office. Not the payment portal. The real office.

Check the inbox first. Helpful clients type all sixteen digits into an email, sometimes with the expiration date and the three-digit code underneath. That email now lives on a mail server, on three phones and in a backup somewhere. Then open the shared drive, where a “client billing” spreadsheet has sprouted a column nobody should have added. Then the CRM notes, the transcribed voicemail, the legal pad by the phone.

And the sticky note. There’s almost always a sticky note.

Every one of those spots pulls more of your business into what PCI calls scope: the people, devices and files the rules cover. One card number in a shared spreadsheet drags in the laptop that opens it, the cloud drive that syncs it and everyone with access to the folder. A lesser-known rule catches people out: you can never keep the security code from the back of a card after the payment goes through. Not encrypted, not in a locked file, not anywhere.

Be honest. If a client called tomorrow and asked who in your office could see their card number, would you know the answer?

How do you stay compliant without becoming a security expert?

Shrink the footprint. That’s the whole strategy.

First, let someone else hold the card. Most invoicing platforms can drop a “pay now” link into every invoice. The client clicks, lands on the processor’s secure page and types the card in themselves. The number never crosses your desk, your inbox or your server. For recurring retainers, ask your processor to keep the card on file. They lock the number in their vault and hand you a stand-in token, so you can charge the retainer every month without ever seeing it.

That one change does most of the work. It often qualifies you for the shortest questionnaire, the one built for businesses that hand the entire transaction to a provider. Taking numbers by phone and keying them into a virtual terminal yourself means a longer form. Keeping numbers in your own files, longer still.

Second, clean house. Delete the card-number column. Purge old emails with card details, then empty the trash. Shred the sticky note. Write down the new rule (we don’t take card numbers by email; here’s the payment link instead) so the whole team says the same thing.

Third, file the questionnaire. Your processor will tell you which version you need, usually through an online portal. With payments on hosted links, it’s often an afternoon’s work. Save the confirmation, called an attestation of compliance, where you’ll find it next year.

Fourth, read your merchant statement every month. Or have someone read it for you.

That last step is where good bookkeeping and payment processing compliance meet. Your bookkeeper already reconciles processor deposits against invoices, so they’re the person most likely to spot an odd fee before it runs for fourteen months. Paul, a System Six client, said the team has been “proactive at catching mistakes I’ve made or seeing challenges coming down the pike.” That’s the job, really. Hear the chirp early.

What does getting it right look like?

Three weeks after that Tuesday, Dana’s office looked the same and worked differently.

Every invoice carried a payment link. Retainer clients on the old spreadsheet got a short note asking them to re-enter their card on the processor’s page. Every one did it within the week. The spreadsheet column disappeared. So did the sticky note. Her office manager filed the questionnaire on a Thursday afternoon, coffee in one hand and the processor’s help page open in another tab. The fee dropped off the next statement.

The bigger change was harder to see on paper. Dana stopped wondering what was sitting in her inbox. When a new client asked how to pay, she had a clean, confident answer. Clients notice that. In a professional services firm, trust is the currency.

Shane, who opened a dental practice with his wife, described bookkeeping as a relationship “where trust needs to be paramount,” and said they wholeheartedly trust the System Six team with their books. That kind of trust gets built in small, unglamorous moments, like catching a $40 fee before it turns into something bigger. It’s part of why System Six, with 175+ businesses served, scores 9.5 out of 10 when clients are asked whether they’d recommend us, and why more than half of our new clients each year come by referral.

So what should you do this week?

Infographic outlining four steps for PCI DSS compliance: never handle card numbers directly, keep card data out of files, stay current on compliance requirements, and check merchant statements for hidden fees.

Here’s the takeaway, and yes, it fits on a sticky note: the safest card number is the one you never see.

PCI compliance sounds like an IT project. For most service firms it’s really a habits project. Send cards through a hosted link, keep numbers out of your files, file the questionnaire once a year and read your merchant statement.

So do one thing today. Pull up last month’s statement and search it for “PCI.” If you find a non-compliance fee, you’ve found your to-do list. And if you’d like a team that reads those statements every month and flags what doesn’t belong, let’s talk.

What’s hiding on yours?

Frequently asked questions

Is PCI compliance required by law?

Not by federal law. PCI DSS is a contract requirement: when you signed your merchant agreement, you agreed to follow it, and your processor enforces it through fees and, after a breach, potential assessments from the card brands. A few states also reference PCI standards in their own data-security laws, so check with your attorney if you operate across several states.

What’s the difference between a PCI compliance fee and a non-compliance fee?

A compliance fee is what some processors charge to run their compliance program, usually a small monthly or annual amount. A non-compliance or non-validation fee is a penalty that appears when you haven’t submitted your annual questionnaire, commonly $20 to $100 or more a month. Paying the first doesn’t make you compliant. Filing the questionnaire stops the second.

Which self-assessment questionnaire does my firm need?

It depends on how you take cards, and your processor will tell you. Firms that send every payment through a provider’s hosted page or payment link often qualify for SAQ A, the shortest. Typing card numbers into a web-based virtual terminal usually means SAQ C-VT. Storing card data on your own systems pushes you toward SAQ D, the longest.

Can we keep client cards on file for monthly retainers?

Yes, as long as your processor stores them and you don’t. Card-on-file (often called tokenization) keeps the number in the processor’s vault and gives you a reference to charge. Never keep the three-digit security code after a payment is authorized, even encrypted.

About System Six

System Six is a Seattle-based outsourced bookkeeping, accounting, payroll, and CFO advisory firm serving consulting and professional services businesses. We work with more than 175 businesses, our team averages over 10 years of accounting experience, and we’ve processed more than $100 million in payroll. Clients rate us 9.5 out of 10 on likelihood to recommend, and over half of our new clients come from referrals. We work on a fixed weekly fee with no long-term contracts. Learn more at systemsix.com.

Weekly vs. Monthly Check-Ins: Finding Your Financial Rhythm

Weekly vs. Monthly Check-Ins: Finding Your Financial Rhythm

Most consulting and professional services firms need both rhythms. A weekly cash flow monitoring check takes about fifteen minutes and answers one question: can we cover the next two weeks? A monthly financial pulse check takes an hour or two, needs closed books, and answers a bigger one: are we headed where we want to go? Weekly keeps you out of trouble. Monthly tells you where you’re going. Skip either one and you’ll usually find out the hard way.

It was 4:40 on a Friday afternoon when Leah noticed the number.

She runs a nine-person brand strategy firm in Seattle. Good clients, good work, a waiting list most quarters. And there she was, staring at her bank balance with payroll due Monday and two big invoices still sitting in some corporate client’s accounts payable queue. The math worked. Barely. She made it through, but she spent the whole weekend doing the kind of mental arithmetic nobody should be doing on a Saturday.

Here’s the thing. Leah’s firm was profitable. Her books were clean. She looked at her financials every month, like you’re supposed to. The problem wasn’t that she wasn’t paying attention. She was paying attention at the wrong tempo.

That’s what this post is about. Not whether cash flow monitoring matters (it does), but how often to do it, what to look at each time, and how to tell which rhythm your firm needs.

Why do so many firm owners check their cash at the wrong time?

Because monthly feels responsible. You close the books, you read the P&L, you nod. Done.

But a monthly review is a rearview mirror. By the time the numbers land on your desk, the month they describe is over. And cash doesn’t move monthly anyway. It moves in lumps. A client pays Net-60, if they pay on time. Payroll hits every two weeks whether or not anyone’s paid you. A quarterly tax payment lands on a random Tuesday. Add project-based revenue, where a big quarter can be followed by a thin one, and you’ve got a business that’s profitable on paper and short on cash on a Friday afternoon.

I spent years reading quality-of-earnings reports before I bought System Six, and this pattern showed up over and over: healthy firms, decent margins, and a cash position that lurched around like a small boat in chop. Nobody was doing anything wrong. They just weren’t looking often enough to see the waves coming.

So what’s the fix? Not more reports. A faster pulse.

What should a weekly cash flow check actually look like?

Infographic outlining four steps for a weekly cash flow check: review available cash, forecast incoming money, plan outgoing payments, and calculate the remaining cash cushion.

Think of it as taking your pulse, not getting a physical. Fifteen minutes, same day every week, same four questions.

What’s in the bank right now? Not what the ledger says, what’s actually cleared. What’s coming in over the next two weeks, and how sure are you about each one? (An invoice that’s twelve days late is not a sure thing.) What’s going out over the next two weeks: payroll, rent, the software stack, that contractor invoice? And the number that matters most: after all of that, how much cushion is left?

That’s it. You’re not reconciling anything. You’re not analyzing margins. You’re answering one question, can we cover the next two weeks comfortably, and writing the answer down so you can see the trend over time.

Leah does hers Monday morning with coffee, before she opens email. Some weeks it takes eight minutes. The payoff isn’t the number itself. It’s that surprises stop being surprises. A slow-paying client shows up as a yellow flag two weeks out instead of a red one two days out, which gives you time to do something useful: send a reminder, shift a payment, hold off on a purchase. Instead of just absorbing the hit.

What belongs in the monthly financial pulse check?

Now zoom out. The weekly check keeps you safe. The monthly check makes you smarter.

This one needs closed books, which means it only works if your bookkeeping is current. (If your books are six weeks behind, your “monthly” review is really a review of two months ago. That’s a different problem, and it comes first.) With clean numbers in hand, you’re asking bigger questions. How did revenue and expenses compare to what you expected? Which clients and projects make money once you count the hours that never got billed? How old is your receivables balance, and which clients are drifting from Net-30 to Net-whenever? And where does your cash forecast stand for the next thirteen weeks? (We walked through building one in our post on rolling forecasts.)

This is where decisions live. Hiring. Raising rates. Dropping a client that’s quietly costing you money. You can’t make those calls from a weekly glance at the bank balance. You need the full picture, and you need it every month, so you can see which way things are trending.

One client put it this way after a year with us: “We have really appreciated the improvements they have made to our bookkeeping process. We are in a much better place today than we were twelve months ago.” That’s Trevor, and the phrase I’d underline is twelve months ago. Monthly reviews compound. Each one makes the next one more useful.

How do you know which rhythm your firm needs?

Most firms need both. But the weighting changes with your situation, and here’s a rough way to think about it.

If you’ve got less than two months of operating expenses in the bank, the weekly check is non-negotiable. Same if your revenue is lumpy: big projects, long payment terms, a couple of clients who make up most of your billings. In those conditions, a lot can go wrong in thirty days.

If you run mostly on steady retainers and you’re sitting on a comfortable cushion, you can lean monthly. But keep the weekly glance. Five minutes with the bank balance costs you nothing and catches the odd surprise.

And if you’re growing fast? Both, religiously. Growth eats cash. You’re hiring ahead of revenue, and the gap between “we signed the client” and “the client paid” is exactly where good firms get into trouble.

There’s one more question worth asking: who’s doing this? If the honest answer is “me, when I remember,” that’s the real problem. The owners who sleep well tend to have someone whose job it is to watch the numbers between meetings. Paul, who runs an investor-backed business, described what that looks like: “Not only have they been mistake free, but S6 has also been proactive at catching mistakes I’ve made or seeing challenges coming down the pike and asking me the right questions to keep the books updated.” Another client, Marcus, said he appreciates how the team is “inquisitive, ask follow on questions, and look around corners.”

That’s what a rhythm is, really. Not a report. Somebody looking around corners on a schedule.

Finding your rhythm

Infographic showing three ways to build a consistent cash flow management routine: make it a weekly habit, share financial monitoring responsibilities, and turn numbers into action.

Leah still does her Monday check. It’s a habit now, like locking the door. But she also stopped being the only person watching, and that’s the part that changed her weekends. Her monthly review now shows up with the books already closed and the questions already asked: what moved, why, and what she should do about it.

Betsy, one of our clients, said it better than I can: “System Six has done wonders for my stress level to feel like this is all now taken care of with a professional partner.” We hear versions of that a lot. Our clients rate us 9.5 out of 10 on how likely they are to recommend us, and more than half of our new clients each year come from referrals. I don’t think that’s because we produce prettier reports. I think it’s because somebody’s taking the pulse every week, so the monthly checkup rarely holds surprises.

So here’s the question: when was the last time you looked at your cash position? And did you look because it was Monday, or because something felt wrong?

If it’s the second one, let’s talk. We’ll help you set the rhythm, and then we’ll keep it for you.

Frequently asked questions

How often should a consulting firm monitor cash flow?

Weekly for the short view (bank balance, cash in and out over the next two weeks, remaining cushion) and monthly for the full picture with closed books, a P&L, receivables aging, and a rolling forecast. Firms with thin cushions or lumpy revenue should treat the weekly check as mandatory.

What is a financial pulse check?

A short, regular review of a handful of numbers that tell you whether the business is healthy right now: cash on hand, money due in, money due out, and the gap between them. It’s deliberately brief so you’ll actually do it every week.

What’s the difference between cash flow monitoring and a cash flow forecast?

Monitoring looks at what’s happening now and over the next couple of weeks. A forecast projects further out, typically thirteen weeks, so you can plan hiring, purchases, and growth. You need both. Monitoring keeps the forecast honest.

Can I do this myself, or do I need an outside team?

You can run the weekly check yourself in fifteen minutes. The monthly check depends on current, accurate books, which is where most owners fall behind. An outsourced finance team keeps the books closed on time and flags issues between reviews.

About System Six

System Six is a Seattle-based outsourced bookkeeping, accounting, payroll, and CFO advisory firm serving consulting and professional services businesses. We work with more than 175 businesses, our team averages over 10 years of accounting experience, and we’ve processed more than $100 million in payroll. Clients rate us 9.5 out of 10 on likelihood to recommend, and over half of our new clients come from referrals. We work on a fixed weekly fee with no long-term contracts. Learn more at systemsix.com.

The Quality of Earnings Checklist: 20 Items Before You Close

The Quality of Earnings Checklist: 20 Items Before You Close

Before I bought my first company, I kept a running list of everything I was afraid the seller’s P&L wasn’t telling me. Three acquisitions later, that list has become the checklist below: twenty items that determine whether the earnings you are buying are real, recurring, and transferable, organized the way a quality of earnings engagement actually works through them.

Use it three ways. Before the LOI, as a filter while you read the CIM. During diligence, as a tracker against your QoE provider’s work. And at the end, as the test of whether you can answer every item with evidence rather than the seller’s assurance. Anything you cannot evidence is either a question for the seller, a finding for the negotiation, or a reason to walk.

Earnings quality (items 1–5)

  1. Proof of cash. Can reported revenue and earnings be traced to actual bank activity, month by month? On unaudited books this is the credibility floor; if cash does not tie, stop here.
  2. Owner compensation normalized. Replace the owner’s actual comp with the market cost of the person who will do that job after close, including the jobs the owner does informally: sales, HR, the Saturday deliveries.
  3. Add-backs that survive the two tests. For every adjustment, ask the replacement test (does this cost truly not exist under my ownership?) and the lender test (will a credit committee accept it?). An add-back that fails either is a negotiating position, not an adjustment.
  4. One-time items that are actually one-time. The fourth consecutive year of one-time legal fees is a recurring cost. Check the same category across all periods before accepting any single-year exclusion.
  5. Related-party transactions at market. Rent to the seller’s LLC, supplies from a cousin’s company, family on payroll. Every related-party line gets restated to the market rate you will actually pay.

Revenue and customers (items 6–10)

  1. Recurring vs. one-time revenue split. How much revenue repeats by contract or by durable behavior, and how much has to be re-won every year? The split drives what multiple the earnings deserve.
  2. Customer concentration. Top-1 and top-5 customer share of revenue, and what actually holds those accounts: contracts that transfer, or the owner’s twenty-year friendships.
  3. Retention and cohort trends. Are customers staying and growing, or is the company refilling a leaky bucket? Churn hiding under headline growth is one of the most common diligence findings.
  4. Price vs. volume growth. Growth that is entirely price increases on a shrinking base looks identical on the P&L to healthy expansion. Decompose it.
  5. Revenue recognition and timing. Deposits booked as revenue, year-end stuffing, work billed ahead of delivery. Check that revenue sits in the right period, especially in the trailing twelve months you are paying on.

Working capital and debt-like items (items 11–15)

  1. Trailing-twelve-month working capital. What does normal working capital actually look like across the full cycle? This becomes the NWC peg, and the peg quietly moves real dollars at close.
  2. Seasonality. A peg set off the wrong months transfers cash from you to the seller. Seasonal businesses need the full-year view, not a convenient quarter.
  3. Deferred revenue. Money collected for work you will have to perform after close is a debt-like item, dollar for dollar. It is also the item sellers most often argue about.
  4. Accrued PTO and payroll liabilities. Earned but unused vacation, bonuses the team expects, payroll run timing. Missing accruals here are both a price issue and a month-one morale issue.
  5. Customer deposits and the debt-like inventory. Deposits, gift cards, warranties, retainage. List everything that behaves like debt and take it off the price before close, not after.

Hidden liabilities and sustainability (items 16–20)

  1. Tax exposure, payroll and sales tax above all. Unpaid payroll taxes and multi-state sales tax nexus follow the business to the new owner. These are the liabilities that show up two years after close with penalties attached.
  2. The month-one cost structure. Below-market wages, thin benefits, missing insurance. Will the earnings the seller is showing you actually show up in month one, at the costs required to keep the team and stay covered?
  3. Maintenance capex vs. depreciation. If the fleet is old and depreciation understates what it costs to keep equipment running, EBITDA flatters the business. Estimate true maintenance capex and subtract it mentally from every earnings figure.
  4. Off-balance-sheet commitments. Leases, purchase commitments, personal guarantees, licenses that do not transfer. Read the contracts, not just the balance sheet.
  5. Accounting changes that flatter the trend. A switch in method, a reclassification, a new capitalization policy in the final year. Any change that makes the trailing twelve months look better than the prior ones deserves a hard look.

How to use this with your QoE provider

Infographic explaining how to use a quality of earnings checklist effectively by reviewing full-scope QoE, matching the scope to the deal, and turning findings into negotiation leverage.

A full-scope QoE covers all twenty items with evidence and schedules; a QoE Lite engagement covers the kill-shot subset: items 1 through 5, a top-level pass on 6 through 8, and a simple working capital look at item 11. Which scope your deal needs depends on size, financing, and complexity; our QoE Lite vs. full-scope guide walks through the decision.

Either way, the checklist keeps you an active buyer rather than a report recipient. The buyers who get the most from diligence are the ones who can look at a finding and already know which item it belongs to and what it should do to price, terms, or the working capital peg.

Frequently asked questions

What is a quality of earnings checklist?

A structured list of the items a QoE engagement tests: earnings quality, add-backs, revenue durability, working capital, debt-like items, and hidden liabilities. It is how buyers track whether the earnings they are paying for are real, recurring, and transferable.

Can I run this checklist myself instead of buying a QoE?

Run it yourself first; it will sharpen every diligence conversation. But lenders and capital partners require independent validation, and a team that has tested hundreds of LMM companies will catch what a first-time buyer cannot. Do both.

How many of these items does a QoE Lite cover?

The kill-shot subset: proof of cash, major add-backs, obvious revenue risks, and a simple working capital analysis. Full scope covers all twenty with quantified findings.